Date
Fri, 3 Jul
Time
14:50 – 15:30, PDT
This presentation examines whether complementarian theology can contribute to environments that enable coercive control within evangelical marriages. Drawing on dissertation research and content analysis of influential evangelical organizations, Bethany Jantzi explores how teachings on male authority and female submission may normalize unequal power dynamics and obscure recognition of abuse. Attendees will gain insight into the intersection of theology, gender, and coercive control, as well as the implications for prevention, education, and support.
This dissertation was undertaken to explore whether complementarian headship theology could be a risk factor for the coercive control of women. This research examines how this theology is framed and discussed, how it is applied in real life, and how it may foster an environment where coercive control is likely.
Evan Stark’s (2007) model of coercive control serves as the central lens through which this ideology was evaluated. Qualitative content analysis was used to scrutinize materials disseminated by two prominent evangelical complementarian organizations: The Council on Biblical Manhood and Womanhood (CBMW) and The Association of Certified Biblical Counselors (ACBC).
The key themes identified through the analysis were God’s Unquestionable Authority, The Husband’s Authority, The Wife’s Submission, and Rhetorical Strategies and Obfuscating Language. A gendered power imbalance was given theological justification through a pervasive emphasis on male authority and female submission. This framework contributed to rationalizing control over women while diminishing their autonomy and personhood.
Significant findings suggest that complementarianism may function as a risk factor for coercive control and may foster environments in which leaders and members are less likely to recognize coercive abuse or respond appropriately. As a widely taught theological framework, the results illustrate how women in these ideological spaces may be particularly vulnerable to coercive control when hierarchical gender roles are framed as spiritual practice and obedience to God.
Watch Recording
This session was recorded at the 2026 Conference and has been uploaded to the website for viewing here*.
*Recordings from the 2026 ICSA International Conference are available on demand for registered conference attendees. You will need to login to your Online Conference Track account to begin watching. If you have not yet created an account, register using the same name and email address used for your conference ticket purchase. Those who did not attend the conference can still purchase an online ticket to gain access here.
Bethany Jantzi is a coercive control consultant and mental health professional, holding an MSc in the Psychology of Coercive Control. She is passionate about helping people understand the intricate mechanisms of coercive control and believes that every person has a right to live free from coercion, abuse, and control. Her research explored high control groups and the weaponization of religious texts as a form of coercive control against women. Other areas of interest are trauma-coerced attachment, grooming, and adult clergy sexual abuse. Bethany’s writing has been published in the academic journal Priscilla Papers, as well as Mutuality Magazine.
Support our mission through membership or by making a donation.
We are actively seeking strategic partnerships that share our commitment to advancing knowledge and understanding in this complex and under-researched field.